As I Lay Dying is Dying After 2 More Members Quit After Bassist’s Departure
The American metalcore group As I Lay Dying is based in San Diego, California. Founded in 2000 by Tim Lambesis.
2 more metal band members Both drummer Nick Pierce and guitarist Ken Susi of As I Lay Dying announced their departures, citing personal reasons as well as the necessity to preserve their integrity and well-being. The band has experienced many difficulties over the years, including the contentious background of their frontman, Tim Lambesis, so this is a serious setback[1].
As I Lay Dying frontman Tim Lambesis has been embroiled in a significant issue. He tried to hire an undercover police officer to kill his estranged wife in 2013[2], which led to his arrest. In 2014, he entered a guilty plea and received a six-year prison sentence.In December 2016, Lambesis was released on parole[3].
He has since rejoined the band and resumed performing, but the episode has had a long-lasting effect on both his and the band’s reputation.
The story is quite intense. What are your thoughts about it? Let me know in the comment section below.
As I Lay Dying Band Members
Over the years, the band’s roster has changed a lot. Among the former members are:
| Name | Role | Years Active |
|---|---|---|
| Jordan Mancino | Drummer | 2000–2014, 2018–2022 |
| Nick Hipa | Lead Guitarist | 2003–2014, 2018–2020 |
| Josh Gilbert | Clean Vocalist | Left in 2022 |
| Clint Norris | Bassist | Left in 2007 |
| Phil Sgrosso | Guitarist | Joined in 2003 |
How has the band’s fanbase reacted to Tim Lambesis’ return?
Fans of As I Lay Dying have had a very mixed response to Tim Lambesis’ comeback. When Lambesis was involved in a murder-for-hire scheme against his estranged wife in 2013, many fans were astonished and dismayed. Reactions were divided when he rejoined the band in 2018 following his public apology and prison sentence[4].
Support from Loyal Fans
Some fans embraced Lambesis’ return, pointing to his stated regret and dedication to self-improvement. These supporters thought he was capable of evolving and that his comeback would restore the band’s initial vigor and imaginative vision. Seeing Lambesis’ return as an opportunity for As I Lay Dying to regain its place in the metalcore scene, this group mostly decided to concentrate on the music and his attempts to turn his life around.
Mixed Feelings and Lingering Uncertainty
The return of Lambesis caused conflicting feelings in many fans. Some were hesitant to fully back him, but they were cautiously hopeful that his second opportunity would have a beneficial impact on the band’s future. These fans frequently stated that they wanted As I Lay Dying to have a happy future, but they were remained skeptical of the band’s capacity to win back their confidence.
Overall, As I Lay Dying’s relationship with its fan base became permanently more convoluted even though Lambesis’ comeback allowed the band to reestablish a connection with longtime fans.
Current Situation of the Band As I Lay Dying
The band members are leaving the band with only two remaining members: Frontman Tim Lambesis and guitarist Phil Sgrosso. The departures are challenging, as the band was preparing to release a new studio album Through Storms Ahead in November 15 2024. Additionally, they have been canceling tour dates following the resignation of their tour manager[5].
| Details | Information |
|---|---|
| Label | Napalm Records |
| Track List | “Permanence”, “A Broken Reflection”, “Burden”, “We Are The Dead” |
| Pre-order | Available now |
Here’s the tracklist.
| Track List |
|---|
| Permanence |
| A Broken Reflection |
| Burden |
| We Are The Dead |
| Whitewashed Tomb |
| Through Storms Ahead |
| The Void Within |
| Strength to Survive |
| Gears That Never Stop |
| The Cave We Fear To Enter |
| Taken From Nothing |
Is there anything else you’d like to know about the album or the band?
What’s Next for As I Lay Dying: Possible Directions for the Band
There are opportunities as well as challenges with the recent lineup alterations. As they try to change their future, As I Lay Dying may go in a number of different directions.
Collaborating with New Talent to Redefine the Band’s Sound
Bringing in new musicians could be one approach. Working with musicians from various backgrounds could result in a synthesis of styles and fresh ideas, revitalizing the sound of As I Lay Dying. While remaining loyal to their metalcore roots, the band may be able to broaden their creative boundaries and reach a new audience by experimenting with aspects from other heavy music genres, such as progressive metal or alternative metal.
Returning to Their Roots and Building Upon Legacy Sound
Reviving the sound that first made As I Lay Dying famous could be another choice, considering the large fan following that connects with the band’s timeless sound. They were able to maintain their individuality and appeal to both new and old fans by adding a contemporary twist to the formula that characterized their early years. This strategy can entail reworking classic components from albums like An Ocean Between Us or Frail Words Collapse, enabling new members to contribute their own flair without deviating too much from the band’s fundamental sound.
Potential Solo Projects or New Bands
Solo endeavors or new musical partnerships might be in the works for the departing members. Hipa, Gilbert, and Mancino have developed sizable fan bases in the metal scene, and their special talents might be useful in other bands or solo projects. A solo career would provide them complete creative autonomy and experimentation, enabling them to pursue musical paths that would not have been feasible inside As I Lay Dying’s framework.
Final Thoughts: The Road Ahead for As I Lay Dying
A new chapter in As I Lay Dying’s history is marked by the departure of important members. The band will probably be forced to reevaluate its identity and artistic direction during this time of change. However, with a legacy as strong as theirs, the band has plenty of room to develop and surprise both reviewers and fans. As I Lay Dying’s next moves will undoubtedly have an impact and be eagerly anticipated by fans, regardless of whether they decide to stay true to their roots or push the envelope with novel viewpoints.
As I Lay Dying rebuilds, everyone will be watching to see if they can reinvent their sound and keep making music that appeals to listeners of all ages. There is little doubt that As I Lay Dying’s spirit lives on and their impact on the metalcore genre is unwavering.
